how firm or runny should starter be?


I have never measured water or flour and now am wanting to do it right :)  My starter is many years old and has been in frig for probably a year.  I will start doing the right percentage now but if I start with too wet or dry, it will throw it off.  Should it be like pancake batter or cookie dough?

148 users have voted.


farinam's picture
farinam 2013 July 20

Hello woodsie8,

Many people use a starter at 100% hydration which just means that you use an equal weight of flour and water to make up/feed your starter.  For a mostly white bread flour this will be more like pancake batter and will thickly coat a spoon.  If you use wholemeal flour only it will be somewhat thicker again.

Some people use what is known as a stiff starter.  This is effectively a piece of dough and is often just that, a piece of dough taken from the previous loaf.

Changing the hydration/stiffness of the dough won't have any drastic effect.  Possibly it will change the balance of bacteria slightly in time that will affect the acid production and as a result the sourness balance but you certainly won't kill it.

Good luck with your projects.


Post Reply

Already a member? Login